|
In the development of the Ranger
mine some fundamental design mistakes were made which continue to cause
problems for ERA, the mine operators, and which annually increase the
risk of contamination of Kakadu.
Rainfall records used to estimate
the total annual rainfall at the Ranger mine site were inaccurate. They
provided an underestimation of actual rainfall. Data used to estimate
the rate at which water would evaporate from the retention ponds overestimated
the evaporation rate. More rain and less evaporation have resulted in
an overall accumulation of polluted water in the mine site. What to
do with this contaminated water is a constant problem at Ranger.
The cheapest way to deal
with excess water is to dump it. Consequently in above average rainfall
seasons, ERA regularly applies to release water into the Magella Creek
system and from there, into the Kakadu National Park wetlands. To date
no release has been permitted. In the 1994/95 wet season ERA went to
court to override the concerns of the downstream traditional owners
and could legally have released contaminated water into the Magella.
ERA has refused to rule out the possibility of releases in the future
and indeed considered it again in the 1995/96 wet season.
Uranium concentrations 100
times the original levels have been recorded in the Magela wetland system
downstream of the mine. Sulfate, manganese, magnesium, copper and zinc
concentrations have also been rising steadily. If this is happening
while ERA are battling to keep the pollutants within the mine boundary,
what is the future of Kakadu when ERA are gone?
The proposed development
of the Jabiluka mine will involve considerable de-watering of the underground
tunnels as the ore is situated below the water table. This contaminated
water will need to be disposed of, adding to the already critical water
management problems.
|